The state of the revolution

As a sort of followup to the previous post comes this bit of news:

In a short telephone interview with Stalin Perez Borges, a national coordinator of the National Union of Workers and leader of the Marea Socialista union current, news and analysis website reported that the Venezuelan National Guard attacked a meeting of workers from Sidor, (Venezuela’s largest steel plant), outside the CVG industrial complex today.

“We want to let everyone know, that while the Sidor workers were concentrated outside the CVG industrial complex, where at 2pm they were to begin an important meeting, members of the National Guard attacked the workers, using among other things, tear gas,” Perez Borges said.

The Sidor workers have been engaged in a dispute for a collective contract for over a year with the management of the Argentine controlled company. Last year, in the framework of Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez’s call to “renationalize everything that was privatized” Sidor workers campaigned for the company to be nationalized and put under worker’s control. However, the company later reached a deal with the government and avoided nationalization.

The key sticking point of the current dispute is the workers demand for a salary increase of 68 Bs. (US$31.6) per day, the company has offered 24 Bs. (US$11.15). In January the Ministry of Labor stepped in to facilitate negotiations between the company management and the United Steel Industry Workers Union (SUTISS), and proposed an intermediary raise of 45 Bs (US$20.9).

SUTISS president José Rodríguez, told the February 27 edition of Correo del Caroni that at first workers welcomed the intervention of the Labor Ministry, however he argued that it is now clear that the Labor Ministry is intervening on behalf of the bosses.

Last week the Labor Minister, criticized a 16 hour strike by the workers on the February 23 as an “error” and proposed a binding arbitration committee, which would have by-passed the union, as a means of resolving the dispute. However, the workers have categorically rejected this proposal and on February 27 activated staggered work stoppages, severely limiting the company’s output. […]

I don’t know many more details about this situation, but it fascinates me. The government encourages nationalization, and when the workers in the factories demand it and worker control, the government, which owns 20 percent of the company, cuts a deal with the company so it can remain private. Then when the workers strike, the government not only sides with the company but sicks the National Guard on them. So the Bolivarian Revolution is, contra the fantasies of many Northern leftists, following the path walked by a thousand and one other revolutions: Taylorism in the factory, redistribution (and, inescapably, repression) by the state. Not that this is a recent development, as the articles collected here make clear, but following on the heals of the defeat of Chavez’s referendum and the fact that suppression is being openly dissected at the usually pro-Chavez, among other indications, it seems that the aporias of statist revolution are becoming clearer and more profound.


One thought on “The state of the revolution

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s